Every December, someone who loves an artist, or really any creative person, goes shopping with the best of intentions and absolutely no idea what to buy. Paint, but which paint? A brush, but which one? A craft kit? That 100-piece set with every color looks like a great deal for the money? You came looking for Christmas gift ideas for artists, or gifts for the creative person in your life, and there are plenty below: the good, the great, and the please don't.

Looking for the best gifts for artists? Whether you're shopping for a painter, watercolorist, sketcher, or someone just getting back into art, this guide is full of thoughtful art gifts they'll actually use. Most recommendations are supplies I've personally bought, loved, or would happily give to another artist—plus a few things I think you should skip. Art supplies are one of the most personal and beloved gifts you can give. Which is exactly why they're so easy to get wrong.